Buy or rent a home? New Middle Tennessee neighborhoods cater to trend in renting

February 15, 2020

Featured in the Tennesseean: https://amp.tennessean.com/amp/4743190002

  • Many individuals and couples who could afford to buy a home in Middle Tennessee are choosing to rent instead, said Bruce McNeilage, CEO and co-founder of Kinloch Partners and Harpeth Development.

  • Harpeth developed Fairview Station, a neighborhood of 30 new houses in Williamson County where every home is for rent.

  • The company also has DerryBerry Estates and Crooked Creek, two similar neighborhoods on the Maury County side of Spring Hill.

Airbnb announced this week that it will ban ‘party houses’ and launch a 24/7 Airbnb Neighbor Hotline.
Mike Fant, The Tennessean

At least for now, Eddie Baida and Darcy McNew are ex-homeowners and that suits them fine.

The couple owned a house in Miami, but when they moved to the Nashville area looking for a better place to raise their children, they decided not to buy right away. They wanted the freedom to move around and check out neighborhoods and schools.

“We wanted to give it a minute to see what the best decision was for us,” said Baida.

Finding a nice, single-family home for rent in Williamson County turned into a challenge.

“I was getting a little desperate. We shared a friend’s house for over a month,” he said.

Then Baida and McNew discovered Fairview Station, a neighborhood of 30 new houses in Williamson County where every home is for rent. They have a four-bedroom house with a two-car garage and space for a den and an office.

“We turned the extra bedroom into a playroom. That way the house stays organized,” said Baida. “The house is perfect for us.”

GET THE LATEST UPDATES:  Download the free Tennessean app on your mobile device

Many individuals and couples who could afford to buy a home are choosing to rent instead, said Bruce McNeilage, CEO and co-founder of Kinloch Partners and Harpeth Development, who developed Fairview Station.

The company also has DerryBerry Estates and Crooked Creek, two similar neighborhoods on the Maury County side of Spring Hill. DerryBerry Estates has 34 homes. McNeilage has 25 houses in Crooked Creek and plans another 37, all built to rent. Other builders are also active in the neighborhood.

Homes in DerryBerry Estates have open interiors. Master baths have soaking tubs and separate showers.
Homes in DerryBerry Estates have open interiors. Master baths have soaking tubs and separate showers.
Submitted

“We have renters who are qualified to buy but have chosen to rent,” said McNeilage.

Some were transferred by an employer and want to be sure the job works out before buying a home. Others sold a home and at least for now want to keep their cash on hand, not tied up in another house. Some are empty nesters who are downsizing but haven’t decided where they want to move.

Frequent travelers to Nashville may find that a rental house can be a cheaper alternative to a hotel. Monthly rents in Fairview Station, for example, range from $1,875 to $1,900. In Crooked Creek and DerryBerry Estates, rents range from $1,600 to $1,775.

“I’m a lot cheaper than two or three nights at the Omni,” said McNeilage.

Then there’s the phenomenon of “grandparents chasing grandkids,” he said.

Parents on a career track may be transferred every few years, and the grandparents follow.

“Grandparents don’t want to be tied down to a house because they have to move on quick notice,” said McNeilage.

Homes in Crooked Creek have granite countertops, stainless appliances and vinyl plank flooring.
Homes in Crooked Creek have granite countertops, stainless appliances and vinyl plank flooring.
Steve Harman / Showcase Photographers

A national trend

The national home building industry has noticed the demand for single-family rentals. Last year, one in 20 new homes was built to rent, not to sell. That was nearly double the historical share, according to Builder Magazine, a publication of the National Association of Home Builders.

Locally, builders may reserve a few homes for rent in a for-sale neighborhood, but McNeilage and one other developer, HND Realty, are the first in the Nashville region to offer entire large subdivisions of single-family homes built for rent.

HND developed The Cottages at Mount View, located in Antioch along a quickly redeveloping stretch of Murfreesboro Pike. The neighborhood offers apartment-style amenities including a fitness center and a swimming pool.

“We’re seeing the phenomenon of renting because you want to. A lot of people are renters by choice, not economic circumstances,” said McNeilage, who is a strong advocate of homeownership and has a standing offer for any of his tenants to buy their house.

“I’ll be happy to sell to you. You never have to leave. Same schools, everything,” he said.

For now, Baida can’t imagine living anyplace other than Fairview Station. His daughter attends Westwood Elementary School next door.

“I can sit on the porch and watch my daughter walk to school and walk in the door,” he said.

From his porch, Eddie Baida can watch his daughter walk to school at Westwood Elementary.
From his porch, Eddie Baida can watch his daughter walk to school at Westwood Elementary.
Submitted
By Bruce McNeilage July 28, 2025
To view this post on "X" please click this link: https://x.com/YahooFinance/status/1949937657582407929
By Bruce McNeilage July 28, 2025
There have been a lot of headlines about the number of investors, both large and small, snapping up homes as investments. Kinloch Partners co-founder & CEO Bruce McNeilage explains who these investors are and why so many are getting into housing. To watch more expert insights and analysis on the latest market action, check out more Asking for a Trend here . Click the image above to watch the entire video. 00:00 Speaker A When we talk about these investors moving in, what kind of investors are we talking about, Bruce? Are we talking about relatively are these smaller investors, or these private equity players? Who are they? 00:18 Bruce Sure, they're all the above, right? They're small mom and pop investors. They're buying four and five houses here and there. They're mid-tier companies like us. We'd like to do another 100 to 200 houses by the end of the year. They're larger players, and then there are the ones in between. Now, family offices, sovereign wealth funds, the hedge funds, the REITs, everybody is coming into the market right now. There's been too much money on the sidelines, and we're really starting to see these builders benefit because they have a lot of excess inventory, and folks like us can come in, clean up their inventory here in the next few months, and really uh help them with their profits and buy up their inventory. 01:06 Speaker A So that's interesting, Bruce. So part of the trend here is its home builders have a lot of inventory. That's part of the the driver here. 01:18 Bruce Yeah, absolutely. Mom and pops are having a tough time qualifying for mortgages, right? The interest rates are just too high in the last 52 weeks. You know, you look at Freddie Mac numbers, they've basically stayed the same. We're hovering just under 7%. People cannot afford mortgages right now. So the next best thing is to rent a brand new house. Well, who do you rent a brand new house from? The people that have bought one, or the people that have built one. And so we're really offering something that most people can't get, a brand new house, instead of buying it, you're renting it. 02:07 Speaker A And the smaller investor, Bruce, in particular, that this was really the trend the kind of journal pointed out here, is there a reason right now, Bruce, that smaller investors would be more active? 02:25 Bruce Yeah, sure. So small investors can borrow money from credit unions. They can borrow against their 401k. They can do a lot of different things that larger investors aren't going to do. And when you see the the price of houses coming down, when you see the inventory come uh going up, and when you also see all these builder incentives, it really helps a small investor get in the game, so to speak, because they are getting these discounts from these builders. 03:05 Speaker A And is the business model there, Bruce, for the smaller investor? It's what, you move in, buy a home, make some modest renovations, rent it with the aim of of one day selling it. Is that the idea? 03:22 Bruce Yeah, most people are looking at either buying a new house or what I call a used house and fixing it up. You cash flow it for a number of years, let's say three to five years. It goes up in value, and then you sell it. A lot of people are just in this for the capital gains. Some people are in it for the income and capital gains, but the name of the game is to have positive cash flow from day one and then sell it at a profit at the end. 03:54 Speaker A Is there are there advantages, Bruce, a smaller investor, relatively would have over a private equity player? 04:08 Bruce Yeah, I think they can be nimble. I don't think they have the same rules. They certainly don't have investment committees. And so they can choose to buy a house, rent a house, sell a house, and they can pay what they want to pay. You know, again, they don't have a mandate from an investment committee. So if they want to buy something with a lower cap rate, if they want to buy something with a higher cap rate or something big, small, uh you know, older, uh newer, they can be as nimble as they want where the larger funds can't. They have mandates. You know, they have a buy box and uh and and they've got some restrictions, and we do too. 04:57 Speaker A I'm sure, Bruce, there are some folks who are watching this right now who think, well, hold on a second. Doesn't this trend, doesn't this thing that Bruce and Josh are talking about ultimately make it that much tougher for regular Americans, Bruce, to come in and bid and compete?  05:25 Bruce Yeah, so you would think that, but what we're doing is we're not taking inventory out of the market. For us, we're building brand new houses, not taking inventory out of the market. And then these houses are available in the MLS. You know, you buy houses from the different large builders. Anybody can buy those houses today. It's just people are not. So investors are coming in, cleaning up this inventory, buying the houses, but quite frankly, they're available to everyone. It's just people can't afford them. So it's buying up the houses and making more stock available again, not to buy, but for people that can't buy but to rent.
By Bruce McNeilage July 28, 2025
High interest rates and prices aren’t deterring firms from snapping up single-family properties
By Bruce McNeilage July 11, 2025
Institutional ownership of rental houses will likely continue for several key reasons:
By Bruce McNeilage June 25, 2025
Why 2025 may test the resilience of commercial real estate as nearly $1 trillion in loans come due.
Show More